Search:

Home | Other Christian


God is Dead - Nietzsche's Blunder

By: Blackstone [Comments (3)]

We've all heard the phrase, right? Whether on a t-shirt, billboard, or in a philosophy textbook, this audacious claim by Nietzsche revolutionized the world we live in. However, despite the limelight claimed by this quote, we rarely think about the implications it carries with it. If God is truly dead, what happens? Or if, as atheists will claim, God never existed, what are the logical conclusions that can be drawn from such a belief? I am not attempting to disprove Nietzsche; rather, I am merely going to extrapolate this idea that "God is Dead", and take it to its logical end. Welcome to the world of Friedrich Nietzsche.

Here is an extended edition of Nietzsche's quote from "The Gay Science":

Have you not heard of that madman who lit a lantern in the bright morning hours, ran to the market-place, and cried incessantly: "I am looking for God! I am looking for God!"
As many of those who did not believe in God were standing together there, he excited considerable laughter. Have you lost him, then? said one. Did he lose his way like a child? said another. Or is he hiding? Is he afraid of us? Has he gone on a voyage? or emigrated? Thus they shouted and laughed. The madman sprang into their midst and pierced them with his glances.

"Where has God gone?" he cried. "I shall tell you. We have killed him - you and I. We are his murderers..."


Nietzsche's reasoning is that we killed God through pity. His cynicism knows no bounds when it comes to discussing the metaphysical.

So, let us say that God is indeed dead; let us assume for a moment that Nietzsche was right. What does this mean?

Nihilism is the outcome. Coming from the Latin "nihil" meaning "nothing", Nihilism basically says that there is no meaning in life. There is no higher authority and there is no moral code that ought to be obeyed. Once this is seen, Darwin's tautology "survival of the fittest" enters into the scene. Nietzsche believed that within everybody is the desire for the ultimate meaninglessness in a meaningless world: power. His annoyance wasn't those who conquered the world as the expense of millions, but rather those who didn't exert themselves on their surroundings to gain power. Basically, Nietzsche loved the Hitlers and hated Mother Teresa. In fact, it has been said that Hitler gave copies of Nietzsche's works to all of his cronies in order to show them the justification for his genocide.

If there is no meaning in life, the only 'meaningful' question is whether or not you should kill yourself. However, even that final action would have no meaning. Henry Ford's quote "History is bunk" is also a logical conclusion from Nihilism. Without meaning, all such things as love, passion, grief, hate, anger, money, power, family, friends, and history have just as much purpose as anything else: nothing.

Now, what's the problem with this idea? The biggest problem is that nobody truly believes in it. To claim "nothing has meaning" is to state, "The only thing that has meaning is that there is no meaning". It is a self-refuting statement along the lines of "I can't type a single word in English". To deny meaning is to deny your own existence. This is why Nietzsche ended up in the madhouse for the ending years of his life.

However, even if somebody claims they are committed to anarchy and nihilism, they are again lying. They will deny the existence of a moral law whenever they want to commit their atrocities, yet will invoke the same moral law whenever injustices happen to them. Their only consistency is their inconsistency.

Nietzsche was a smart guy, but not that smart. Blinded to the truth, he searched for meaning in his meaningless philosophy. Such is the path of all atheists. To loosely quote Henry Ford, "Meaninglessness is bunk".

Article Source: http://www.christianarticledirectory.org

Please Rate this Article

 

# of Ratings = 5 | Rating = 2.6/5

Click the XML Icon Above to Receive Other Christian Articles Via RSS!
» 
» 
Top Christian Websites

Powered by Article Dashboard